HomemadeTurbo - DIY Turbo Forum

HomemadeTurbo - DIY Turbo Forum (https://www.homemadeturbo.com/)
-   General Discussion (https://www.homemadeturbo.com/general-discussion-6/)
-   -   XTD scam?? (https://www.homemadeturbo.com/general-discussion-6/xtd-scam-88408/)

Oscar 01-26-2008 09:18 PM

XTD scam??
 
got this off another forum

We are having clutches made for us by Action Clutch. They make us an upgraded pressure plate that is 40% heavier spring pressure then stock. Recently, someone brought to my attention the they could buy the "same thing" on Ebay for over $200 less. I was REALLY supprised to hear that, because we don't have a lot of margin on ours, and I was wondering if we were just paying way too much, or if it was too good to be true. Since XTD is only about a 45 minute drive from the shop, I went there in person to check it out. He seems to do a lot of business on Ebay, there were about 20 orders boxed up to go out, and since many of them were not taped up, I noticed that he had more then a few 7m-gte clutches to be shipped. At the bottom of a huge stack of Aisin (oem toyota) boxes, I saw a few Action clutch boxes. That was strange, because Action said the do not sell anything to this guy, and they were wondering why he had their boxes in his business. I found out why!

I bought one of his pressure plates to take to Action to test, and to take pics compared to stock. THE XTD PRESSURE PLATE IS A BONE STOCK PRESSURE PLATE, SPRAY PAINTED RED. We had Action put it on their pressure test machine that tests the clamp pressure, and also a stock Aisin Toyota pressure plate. The XTD clutch was actually 100ft/lbs LESS then the other stock unit we tested. His Ebay auction clearly states the XTD pressure plate is "35% thicker heavy duty" spring in it. I measured the XTD and stock springs, they are exactly the same thickness. He is clearly lying, and fooling people into thinking the XTD clutch will handle 35% more, when in fact it is stock. If you remove the XTD sticker, you will see the stock green paint mark underneath :biglaugh: If they were heat treated to increase the spring pressure, that paint would most likely have burned off, and the spring would be discolored.

Also, I looked closely at the XTD 6 puck disk. It looks like a cheap copy of the Action one. If you look at the pics in his Ebay auction at the top it is an ACTION CLUTCH KIT IN THE PICS. The one he actually ships is in the pics at the bottom. Action clutch does use a stock Aisin outer clutch cover, but the rivets are drilled out, and then the spring is upgraded and the clutch is reassembled. Other companies also do this, because Aisin is the only manufacturer of this model clutch.

Here is a link to his auction on Ebay. If you want to be overcharged for a stock pp with cheap copy 6 puck, that's up to you.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/XTD-...106058632QQrdZ1
Notice the first pic on his Ebay auction is an Action Clutch pp with an XTD sticker on it. You can tell because the spring is dark black, and the pp was disassembled before painting. You can see around the inside edge at the top.

Here's what he is actually shipping:
https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v...0590Medium.jpg
https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v...0589Medium.jpg
Compared to a stock pp:
https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v...0603Medium.jpg

The real Action upgraded clutch has a black spring and is painted while it is disassembled. It has a 40% higher pressure spring then stock.
https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v...0478Medium.jpg
The real Action 6 puck has a slightly lighter color on the pucks, and has little slots in the center of each puck.
https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v...0479Medium.jpg

I really don't have a problem with Ebay, or Chinese made parts, what I do have a BIG problem with is people on Ebay misrepresenting the specs and performance of their parts.
My stage2 XTD clutch disc is pretty much ---- after only 1 year. I have less than 150whp too. :l

J-MAN 01-26-2008 09:24 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
good heads up

Oscar 01-26-2008 09:30 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
here's another thread about some guy getting ripped off
http://forums.nicoclub.com/zerothread?id=146630

Same thing happened to me, only it took a little bit longer. Mostly cus the car was down for a long time, lol.

kain 01-26-2008 09:33 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
thats why i got mine for free.

exedy extreme clutch. all for free.

Oscar 01-26-2008 09:35 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
how?

QikEnuF 01-26-2008 09:37 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
He fucked Hotrex, who just happened to have a spare clutch...

Dr.Boost 01-26-2008 09:40 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by QikEnuF
He fucked Hotrex, who just happened to have a spare clutch...

And he shipped it??? ???
__________________
Best Car Insurance | Auto Protection Today | FREE Trade-In Quote

QikEnuF 01-26-2008 09:42 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by Dr.Boost
And he shipped it??? ???

Didn't have to, since Kain was right there :1
However, the welds may crack I hear...

Sinner 01-26-2008 09:46 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
my puck clutch from xtd has held up very good with two years of straight O0 abuse 15lb+. Dumping it many times because i'm a ---- head. No complaints from me. I'd buy from them again :8

kain 01-26-2008 10:14 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by QikEnuF
Didn't have to, since Kain was right there :1
However, the welds may crack I hear...

ha ha ha. your failed attempt at internet humor is somewhat interesting, but i must digress from the current failure.


i got a clutch kit for 450 dollars on ebay, however the vendor didn't have the item in stock. i told him to refund me and he did, but he sent it out anyways. well, he found out and e-mailed me asking for money, but then i just never replied back.

Dr.Boost 01-26-2008 10:16 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by kain

i got a clutch kit for 450 dollars on ebay, however the vendor didn't have the item in stock. i told him to refund me and he did, but he sent it out anyways. well, he found out and e-mailed me asking for money, but then i just never replied back.

Karma will keep you a midget virgin for the rest of your life. >:D
__________________
Best Car Insurance | Auto Protection Today | FREE Trade-In Quote

kain 01-26-2008 10:33 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by Dr.Boost
Karma will keep you a midget virgin for the rest of your life. >:D

ive delt with that possibility by now dont you think?

RedCavz 01-26-2008 10:50 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
ive heard way more good stories about that place than i have bad, so i dont really believe this. peopl have made lots of power on those cheap peices of trash :8

Oscar 01-26-2008 10:54 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by 98redcavz24
ive heard way more good stories about that place than i have bad, so i dont really believe this. peopl have made lots of power on those cheap peices of trash :8

yea, I know people that run them without problems.

Seems like it's the stage 2's that have the most problem. I know mine didn't even last a year really.

MustangC. 01-26-2008 11:28 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
those are homo toyota clutches. who cars if XTD fucks those faggots. all i know is my stage 4 XTD takes the abuse like a ------- champ. ive used a few of thier clutches and have yet to have a problem. for 150 shipped i dont care if it only lasts 6 months.

QikEnuF 01-26-2008 11:50 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
A lot of the V6, and I guess since Pete posted, 4 banger Jbody guys have had really good luck with their clutches, few V6 folks pushing over 400 ft/lbs on some of the 3400 motors.

HMTguy 01-27-2008 12:30 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
Yea I've ran an XTD "stage 3" 6-puck for almost 3 years now and it's great. Not sure how it will handle 300+ whp this spring though :l

scottsi 01-27-2008 12:41 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
I had a XTD sprung 6 puck in my 300zx, it held good. Probably not as stiff as i would have liked for a 6 puck but held power none-the-less

On a side note I'd like to deter people from ACT clutches, as they are crap, i've have 2 break on me and one within 6k, i know how to drive and i dont sit on the clutch, nor do i slip it hard. They were raced on as they were designed to take it, but even making 40-50les hp/tq than rated they still did not last.

SQ is the SQUAD 01-27-2008 12:44 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
i got a xtd 6 puck 4663 clutch kit. i havent ran it, but it ewassent over sprayed painted like the toyota one

Oscar 01-27-2008 12:52 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/XTD-S...em180208882496

I was looking at that one b/c I havent heard anything bad from the stage 3's, but if you look at the pressure plate, you can tell it was spray painted. :1

stillnoturbo 01-27-2008 02:00 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
I can't remember what stage I had but it was a sprung 6 puck. It would slip on the highway but would chirp going into 3rd. It held up good to numerous clutch kicks and smoked out my stock diff in my old Hachi. Ripped all the teeth off my pinion gear after a month. Then I pulled the whole 3rd member out and threw in a brand new TRD 2way diff and 3rd member housing setup from Toysport. It held up fine but started to hum pretty good after about 3 months of daily clutch kicks and just beating on the car and then it started to sound just like the stock rearend before it blew out. Then I didn't want to deal with messing with it and sold it.

ifly87 01-27-2008 02:31 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
No ---- they're stock PP's with a cheap ass clutch disk...its what they all are. spray painted purple or blue or red. That guy is smart as hell making tons of cash.

MustangC. 01-27-2008 02:48 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by d112crzy
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/XTD-S...em180208882496

I was looking at that one b/c I havent heard anything bad from the stage 3's, but if you look at the pressure plate, you can tell it was spray painted. :1

really?? i thought they used colored steel :1 :1 :1

SDRAWKCAB 01-27-2008 03:55 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
Its a 150 dollar shipped clutch so STFU already.
I got a 6 puck ACT for 40 dollars shipped and have no complaints. ;)

Donald125 01-27-2008 05:35 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
driftmotion huh, funny how i know every------- vender

Random Hero 01-27-2008 10:04 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
lol that sucks. I told spiker his clutch on his f22 felt stockish/less then stock

SpankedYA! 01-27-2008 10:30 AM

Re: XTD scam??
 
Every XTD clutch I have owned has slipped. The one in my green civic I just got rid of ---- out with about 1k on it. Granted it was a stageII and the car makes 185hp and 175ft lbs. My XTD CRX LS clutch was a 6 puck and was ---- out of the box.

Oscar 01-27-2008 12:04 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by CoreyR
really?? i thought they used colored steel :1 :1 :1

I was just reinforcing what was said in the first post about quality. They paint em assembled. That just shows the lack quality.


They're cheap clutches, but it's a pain in the ass for someone that buys them as a replacement and they go out with stock power in less than a year.

I posted this as a heads up for anyone that's in the same boat as me.

IntaCooler 01-27-2008 01:11 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
xtd = seco

-SKUM- 01-27-2008 01:24 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
My xtd stg3 with my a6 and 12lbs from a to4 dose good untill it gets hot,(ass dyno says around 200hp) But im talking about smoking hot. Ive only had it slip on me about 3-4 times. But I was beating on it for over 20min each time. Lost of short downshifts, and then smashing on it at 5k. For $150 bucks I cant bitch. Besides the chaddering I get, its been a good clutch.

one2many 01-27-2008 02:48 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

26Xtq on a old ass xtd stage 3. N0 issues. ;D


resurfacing the flywheel is key. 8)






jacer63 01-27-2008 02:50 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
ive had 2 XTD's stage 2-3 and they suck donkey ass. went with a centerforce df and it owns.
the xtd would slip all time and chatter, and yes i broke it in for 500miles driving easy. then the rivets fell out of the disc??.. for 150 not bad price but still junk.

Oscar 01-27-2008 02:52 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
I decided I'm gona go with an LSD clutch kit. Haven't heard anything bad about them and they're very wallet friendly.

RotaryGeek 01-27-2008 02:56 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
the remote mount rex in my driveway has an xtd stage 3 in it that was beat on to hell in a old turbo z6 setup and it still works pretty good. its slipping now, but thats with 10k of hard driving on it.

BigD 01-27-2008 03:19 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
I had a stage 2 in my civic and it felt like ----. Glad I got rid of it within a month.

Smith-02 01-27-2008 03:35 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
you guys DO realize the clutch in question was the xtd clutch for the 7mgte right? it doesn't exactly apply to all of their clutches

Oscar 01-27-2008 03:36 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
If they do it for one, what makes you think they're not doing it for the rest or just some of the rest?

You have both good and bad reviews in one thread. Mostly bad. People can choose to throw away their money and time if they wish.

crx2fast 01-27-2008 03:43 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
clucth masters for life!

Smith-02 01-27-2008 03:46 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 

Originally Posted by d112crzy
If they do it for one, what makes you think they're not doing it for the rest or just some of the rest?

You have both good and bad reviews in one thread. Mostly bad. People can choose to throw away their money and time if they wish.

point taken, another example would be gp sorensen, and world class. advance auto house brand, they have a LOT of 'remanufactured' parts that are cleaned off crusty old calipers and alternators, painted, and thrown in a box. i've had mixed experiences with them, i bought rear wheel slave cyls, and the pistons would blow out all the time. front caliper, the piston would stick if i did hard braking and glaze pads. numerous electronics parts, they're usually okay, but i've had DOA parts, and they won't exchange them. also had a upper rad hose, and it split like a banana one day, and warped my head by the time i knew it happened (70mph tends to not drift steam in plain sight)

90dx 01-27-2008 11:31 PM

Re: XTD scam??
 
XTD FTW :D I ran there stage three with there light weight flywheel in my Civic and it held up very well.The car was a little over 300whp,running 24.5" slicks launching on the antilag at 14psi all day.I would use another for any sub 400whp builds :6


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:43 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands